This document is provided for general informational purposes only and does not constitute legal, tax, accounting, insurance, brokerage, risk management, or other professional advice. You should consult your own legal counsel or other qualified professional advisors regarding your specific circumstances, and receipt of this document does not create any client, advisory, fiduciary, brokerage, or other professional relationship with Alliant Insurance Services, Inc. This document is provided “as is” without warranty of any kind, and Alliant Insurance Services, Inc. disclaims any liability for any loss or damage arising out of or relating to reliance on this document.
Women in Sales: How to Create Memorable Client Experiences
By Alliant Property & Casualty
How can small, thoughtful actions make clients feel understood and strengthen business relationships?
In this episode of Women in Sales, host Jenni Lee Crocker talks with Brandon Pope, Vaco, about creating “magical moments” through a simple approach: notice, remember and respond. Brandon shares how listening closely, documenting client preferences and anticipating what matters next can turn everyday service into a memorable experience. They also discuss thoughtful ways to recognize centers of influence and why meaningful gestures don’t need to be expensive or elaborate.
Find us on Apple Podcasts, Spotify & YouTube
Welcome (00:03):
Welcome to Women in Sales, a podcast hosted by Jenni Lee Crocker, where we spotlight the voices, stories, and strategies shaping the future of sales. In each episode, Jenni Lee sits down with inspiring women across industries to share real experiences, practical insights, and lessons from their journeys to success. Now, let's get started.
Jenni Lee Crocker (00:31):
Oh hi Brandon. It's nice to see you. Welcome to episode six for Women in Sales. I'm so grateful that you could join us, and big deal, you were the first male guest we've had on this podcast, and there's a reason for that. First of all, we celebrate all of our supporters and allies, and you are absolutely one. Before I ask you to introduce yourself, I do want to introduce the topic.
Brandon Pope (00:56):
Please.
Jenni Lee Crocker (00:57):
You gave me this great idea at breakfast after a workout one morning, you invited me to a workout, which is a magical moment for me, that created a lot of trust for me. But you said that you like to make magical moments for your clients, and I, like, paused and got the chills, and I said, "Tell me about that, because I love the idea of delighting my client, but the way you said it felt different. So could you introduce yourself and talk to us about that magical moment?"
Brandon Pope (01:25):
Absolutely. But I first have to acknowledge what an honor it is to be here because the future 100% is female, so I am honored to be here and love this podcast and what you're trying to do with it. The idea behind magical moments is 100% me copying off of other people's papers that have come before me. Our former CEO was famous for this term and really embodying it so well. But it is this idea that we can do ordinary things extraordinarily well, but also the fact that I think when people hear the term magical moment, they sometimes picture a huge gift or an elaborate surprise. Right. But oftentimes, it's much simpler than that. It is a moment the client realizes, "Wow, they really listened to me. They remembered and they cared enough to act on it." So that's kind of the boundary that I would put around it.
Jenni Lee Crocker (02:19):
So talk to me about... well first of all, Brandon Pope, Vaco. Maybe we should say that
Brandon Pope (02:25):
I'm sorry, yes. Brandon Pope, CPA, Vaco. yeah, I love accounting and finance. I love helping people find accounting and finance jobs and love helping people find their purpose and become the best version of themselves. Inside and outside the gym.
Jenni Lee Crocker (02:43):
Exactly. Also a fitness coach. Okay. <laugh> First of all, I love ordinary things extraordinarily well. That's delightful to me. What makes a client experience magical versus satisfactory? In your world, show me the difference.
Brandon Pope (02:58):
I think if you talk to any general salesperson, they would say, "Hey you know, it's really important to ask questions of your client." And I would agree with that litmus test. But the difference can then become what type of questions and how well do you listen when you ask them? But the difference between satisfactory and magical can even be the service was delivered correctly. That's satisfaction. But magical might be where the client actually felt understood and cared for. Satisfaction is when you answer a request, but magical is when you anticipated what would matter next. So efficient can be satisfactory, but memorable is really where magic comes in there.
Jenni Lee Crocker (03:42):
So memorable in the sense that if I'm your client and I tell you, "Hey, my busy season is between September 15th and October 15th, let's make certain we stay out of those parameters as we're closing this deal. By the by, I prefer morning meetings and I don't like late dinners," those types of things. And so you come in not only at the right timing, but you were mindful of my needs. Am I getting it right? And you listen to all those little things that are actually important to me?
Brandon Pope (04:13):
100%. I think it really breaks down into three parts. Notice, remember, respond. So noticing what's going on, to your point you were just talking about, is this a busy season for me? What pressure is my client carrying? What personal detail did they mention? Remembering it is where the organization and to what we do matters of capturing what we hear. And unfortunately, as good intentions as we all are, good intentions are not a system. So really documenting that well in your own personal way, but whether that's a personal preference, an important milestone, or even just to your point, like a communication style, remembering that is important. We have certain clients that are persnickety maybe is a good term to use and it's important to remember how they want to be communicated with. But then that third piece is critically important of responding. So if it is a busy season, how do you respond? Do you respond? You know, how can you be helpful in that period of time? And I think that piece particularly is how attention becomes an experience and anticipation becomes magical in that moment.
Jenni Lee Crocker (05:20):
So what's your system for that notice, remember, respond? Everybody keeps something different, but if I'm your client and you hear all these things from me, what's your next step?
Brandon Pope (05:31):
Gosh, I'm so guilty of thinking I can remember everything. And the older I get, the more I realize I can not assume anything. So what I try to do is after I meet with somebody, I will just sit in my car before I go somewhere else or if I'm at my office, at my desk, before I answer any emails or pick up the phone to call somebody else, I'm going to document there in as much detail as I can. I got this from a colleague of mine who does exceptionally well. He always writes a note to his future self. So when you look back at that note, you remember what the action item was. So let's say, "Hey, met with Jenni Lee. you know, we're going to talk about this, but here's the next thing I'm going to do, whether that's in a month, two months, three months." And then when that pops up again, I don't have to rethink through our interaction. Future Me is so proud right now because I documented it well enough.
Jenni Lee Crocker (06:22):
Right. Future Me loves Yesterday Me. That is great. I have never thought of that. You know, maybe we also talk about COIs and magical moments. I'll give you an example and I bet you can one-up me. You know, in our business, often you and I get referrals, right? Brandon will say, Jenni Lee, call Acme Company. Let me make an introduction for you. They need a new broker. Gosh, thanks, Brandon. I have a note for future self. When I get that meeting or I have a good meeting or an interaction with that person where there was an introduction, I immediately get back to Brandon to say, "I want to thank you. I held a meeting with that person on X date. We discussed blank. I am so grateful for this." And if I close the business, I do go back and create a magical moment of there is a gift or a lunch or a dinner or something of a thank you. I take my COIs very seriously and I respect that relationship and the respect between the two of us. Tell me how you honor that notice, remember, respect with your COIs.
Brandon Pope (07:26):
That's a really good example, Jenni Lee. And I'm so incredibly inspired by what you already shared. But I will say, you know, I think rewarding people for helping you out and remembering that is a key. One of the things I like to do is, again, this conversation's not around big extravagant moments or gifts, but one of my favorite things is, you know, whether it's a bottle of wine or something else, I like to take a Sharpie and write a message on the actual bottle and hand it to them because oftentimes they get a gift from somebody else or a bottle of wine and, you know, thanks, no thanks. But the message is right there on the bottle and that goes a step further or, gosh, it's 2026 and a handwritten note seems like such a novelty. But the time that it takes to literally put pen to paper and then send it to them goes a long way. I can't remember the last time I sent a handwritten note where I didn't get a response back of, "Oh my gosh, friend, this made my day. I can't remember the last time I got one of these." And I think that's just really unfortunate, honestly.
Jenni Lee Crocker (08:29):
Well, right. You get into the concept of a magical moment is not performative and it's not necessarily expensive. I think people, when they hear that, they immediately think a round of golf at a very expensive club, but not necessarily. It is the notice, remember, respond, as you said, and neither one of those, in what you're saying to me, has to be performative or expensive.
Brandon Pope (08:50):
It is funny because magical moments are not created equally, and a five-minute gesture can carry the weight of five months of relationship building if it arrives at exactly the right moment. So to your point, it doesn't have to be some grand gesture, but it could be remembering a personal milestone or checking in after a difficult event. You and I both know Amy Miller. She is so good about connecting with people at a heart level, and she's always been there to respond to people when they go through tough times or exciting times...
Jenni Lee Crocker (09:22):
She remembers everything...
Brandon Pope (09:24):
She's so good.
Jenni Lee Crocker (09:25):
Yes. That shows her empathy level. What about other brands, external brands that you think are really good at this? I always think of hospitality, right? I know that Marriott, now Marriott should treat me well because of all of my travel. But they do. But they do. Yeah. And it's rarely performative or expensive, but they know a lot about me and my profile that people are clearly typing in.
Brandon Pope (09:50):
That's a good one. This will give a little bit more insight into my life stage that I'm in, but I have a young little one at home, and there's so many different brands that we interact with, like Love Every or House of Noah. There's these little mats that you make a playroom out of, and that doesn't seem like that's that important or could be a sticky customer type of moment. But we had this situation where they were rubbing wrong and the material was breaking and they sent us all new mats without any questions asked. And I was like, "Wow, they got a customer for life for that because any other brand would have been like, "Hey, this is outside of a return policy or we can send you a repair for this." They just said, "Hey, we got this.", to me, I think that what is impactful, particularly as a young parent, is knowing the season your customer's in. So for me, this is a stressful time <laugh> in parenting, particularly with young ones. And they took that so much further than they needed to going above and beyond when we did not even ask for it.
Jenni Lee Crocker (10:53):
You call it the magic moment. I call it the delight moment. I seek to delight and I think that's part of my personal drive to serve with passion. And maybe that is even selfish because I think serving with passion means I'm having fun. So if I'm having fun serving my clients, I'm serving with passion and I'm more likely to delight you. Now, you got at it from a way that I think is more process-driven and I like it and I've taken some notes...
Brandon Pope (11:17):
That's the CPN here...
Jenni Lee Crocker (11:19):
Right, right. But to me, it seems like you should be able to measure loyalty, referrals, retention. You can't measure emotional connection but I'm thinking that, you know, they say a great salesperson closes 30% of the deals, but I'm guessing you probably have a higher close rate.
Brandon Pope (11:37):
Yeah. I think part of that too is we call it playing closest to the dollar. And that's knowing where your time is best spent but also loving on your clients really well because that attitude of gratitude creates exclusivity where we know when they reach out to us, they are counting on us to deliver. And to your point, I want to have fun. We're all having fun. And when we do our jobs really well, then the fun just falls into place. So I appreciate that.
Jenni Lee Crocker (12:09):
I love this. Thank you for this, Brandon. Yeah. I've taken a lot of notes while I've been trying to speak to you, but doing ordinary things extraordinarily well. Notice, remember, respond. In our last few moments, anything else you want to share?
Brandon Pope (12:24):
I think if listeners remember one thing, I hope it's the fact that creating magical moments does not require a huge budget or a grand idea. I would just encourage you to find one person, remember one detail, and do one thoughtful thing with it. Make it personal, make it useful, and do it without asking anything in return. I think that's really when people begin to feel seen and valued and remembered.
Jenni Lee Crocker (12:48):
Love it. Well, you have been the best first male guest we've had, and you nailed it. Way to go. <laugh> Thank you, Brandon. All right. So thank you.
Brandon Pope (12:58):
Thanks, Jenni.
Jenni Lee Crocker (12:59):
Really enjoyed having you.
Brandon Pope (13:00):
My pleasure.
Closing (13:03):
Thank you for listening to Women in Sales with Jenni Lee Crocker. If you enjoyed this episode, be sure to subscribe, share it with a colleague, and leave a review to help more women discover these conversations. We'll see you next time for more stories, insights, and inspiration from women leading the way in sales.
Thanks for your message.
We’ll be in touch shortly